communications Failures

Case Study: COMMUNICATIONS FAILURES
Kerzner, Harold. Project Management (Kindle Locations 8021-8100) Wiley. Kindle Edition
Page: 1 of 3
PMGT 540 Harrisburg University
Background
Herb had been with the company for more than eight years and had worked on various R& D
and product enhancement projects for external clients. He had a Ph.D. in engineering and had
developed a reputation as a subject matter expert. Because of his specialized skills, he worked
by himself most of the time and interfaced with the various project teams only during project
team meetings. All of that was about to change. Herb’s company had just won a two-year
contract from one of its best customers. The first year of the contract would be R& D and the
second year would be manufacturing. The company made the decision that the best person
qualified to be the project manager was Herb because of his knowledge of R& D and
manufacturing. Unfortunately, Herb had never taken any courses in project management, and
because of his limited involvement with previous project teams, there were risks in assigning
him as the project manager. But management believed he could do the job.
The team is formed
Herb’s team consisted of fourteen people, most of whom would be full-time for at least the
first year of the project. The four people who Herb would be interfacing with on a daily basis
were Alice, Bob, Betty, and Frank.
 Alice was a seasoned veteran who worked with Herb in R& D. Alice had been with the
company longer than Herb and would coordinate the efforts of the R& D personnel.
 Bob also had been with the company longer than Herb and had spent his career in
engineering. Bob would coordinate the engineering efforts and drafting.
 Betty was relatively new to the company. She would be responsible for all reports,
records management, and procurements.
 Frank, a five-year employee with the company, was a manufacturing engineer. Unlike
Alice, Bob, and Betty, Frank would be part-time on the project until it was time to
prepare the manufacturing plans.
For the first two months of the program, work seemed to be progressing as planned. Everyone
understood their role on the project and there were no critical issues.
Friday the 13th
Herb held weekly team meetings every Friday from 2: 00 to 3: 00 P.M.
Unfortunately, the next team meeting would fall on Friday the 13th, and that bothered Herb
because he was somewhat superstitious. He was considering canceling the team meeting just
for that week but decided against it.
Case Study: COMMUNICATIONS FAILURES
Kerzner, Harold. Project Management (Kindle Locations 8021-8100) Wiley. Kindle Edition
Page: 2 of 3
PMGT 540 Harrisburg University
At 9: 00 A.M. on Friday the 13th, Herb met with his project sponsor as he always did in the past.
Two days before, Herb casually talked to his sponsor in the hallway and the sponsor told Herb
that on Friday the sponsor would like to discuss the cash flow projections for the next six
months and have a discussion on ways to reduce some of the expenditures. The sponsor had
seen some expenditures that bothered him. As soon as Herb entered the sponsor’s office, the
sponsor said:
It looks like you have no report with you. I specifically recall asking you for a report on
the cash flow projections.
Herb was somewhat displeased over this. He specifically recalled that this was to be a
discussion only and no report was requested. But Herb knew that “rank has its privileges” and
questioning the sponsor’s communication skills would be wrong. Obviously, this was not a good
start to Friday the 13th.
At 10: 00 A.M., Alice came into Herb’s office and he could see from the expression on her face
that she was somewhat distraught. Alice then spoke:
Herb, last Monday I told you that the company was considering me for promotion and
the announcements would be made this morning. Well, I did not get promoted. How
come you never wrote a letter of recommendation for me?
Herb remembered the conversation vividly. Alice did say that she was being considered for
promotion but never asked him to write a letter of recommendation. Did Alice expect Herb to
read between the lines and try to figure out what she really meant?
Herb expressed his sincere apologies for what happened. Unfortunately, this did not make Alice
feel any better as she stormed out of Herb’s office. Obviously, Herb’s day was getting worse
and it was Friday the 13th.
No sooner had Alice exited the doorway to Herb’s office when Bob entered. Herb could tell that
Bob had a problem. Bob then stated:
In one of our team meetings last month, you stated that you had personally contacted
some of my engineering technicians and told them to perform this week’s tests at 70 ° F,
90 ° F, and 110 ° F. You and I know that the specifications called for testing at 60 ° F, 80 °
F, and 100 ° F. That’s the way it was always done, and you were asking them to perform
the tests at different intervals than the specifications called for.
Well, it seems that the engineering technicians forgot the conversation you had with
them and did the tests according to the specification criteria. I assumed that you had
followed up your conversation with them with a memo, but that was not the case. It
seems that they forgot.
Case Study: COMMUNICATIONS FAILURES
Kerzner, Harold. Project Management (Kindle Locations 8021-8100) Wiley. Kindle Edition
Page: 3 of 3
PMGT 540 Harrisburg University
When dealing with my engineering technicians, the standard rule is, “If it’s not in
writing, then it hasn’t been said.” From now on, I would recommend that you let me
provide the direction to my engineering technicians. My responsibility is engineering,
and all requests of my engineering personnel should go through me.
Yes, Friday the 13th had become a very bad day for Herb. What else could go wrong, Herb
thought. It was now 11: 30 A.M. and almost time for lunch. Herb was considering locking his
office door so that nobody could find him and then disconnecting his phone. But in walked
Betty and Frank, and once again he could tell by the expressions on their faces that they had a
problem. Frank spoke first:
I just received confirmation from procurement that they purchased certain materials
that we will need when we begin manufacturing. We are a year away from beginning
manufacturing and, if the final design changes in the slightest, we will be stuck with
costly raw materials that cannot be used. Also, my manufacturing budget did not have
the cash flow for early procurement. I should be involved in all procurement decisions
involving manufacturing. I might have been able to get it cheaper that Betty did. So, how
was this decision made without me?
Before Herb could say anything, Betty spoke up:
Last month, Herb, you asked me to look into the cost of procuring these materials. I
found a great price at one of the vendors and made the decision to purchase them. I
thought that this was what you wanted me to do. This is how we did it in the last
company I worked for.
Herb then remarked:
I just wanted you to determine what the cost would be, not to make the final
procurement decision, which is not your responsibility.
Friday the 13th was becoming possibly the worst day in Herb’s life. Herb decided not to take
any further chances. As soon as Betty and Frank left, Herb immediately sent out emails to all of
the team members canceling the team meeting scheduled for 2: 00 to 3: 00 P.M. that
afternoon.
QUESTIONS
1. How important are communication skills in project management?
2. Was Herb the right person to be assigned as the project manager?
3. There were communications issues with Alice, Bob, Betty, and Frank. For each
communication issue, where was the breakdown in communications: encoding,
decoding, feedback, and so on?
Source: © 2010 by Harold Kerzner. Reproduced by permission. All rights reserved.

After reading the case study, answer questions 1 – 3 in your initial discussion post.  Use experience from your past as well as information from your reading.  Your post response should be supported by citing at least one passage from either the Kerzner text or the PMBOK.  (6 Points)